I know I should like Veronica Mars. But I don't.
I love Buffy, I love Party Down, I love Kristen Bell, Ryan Hansen (Burning Love!!!), everything and everyone associated with Veronica Mars except for the actual show. I've tried to get into it, I've watched the movie, I've read countless essays about it. But it doesn't do anything for me (I'm totally down for convincing arguments in the comments, by the way).
So, people! What's the thing you know you should love but you just can't seem to get into?
Post your "Should Love But Don't" stories below!
ETA: my second "Should Love But Don't" is probably Meryl Streep.